If you take a drive down to the corner of Fitzhugh and Bryan Street in Dallas you're going to pass an old building with a red, white and green awning and signs touting Italian wines, coffee, and fresh meats and sausages. From the looks of the place you'd never suspect that deep inside they not only have these amazing options but also a meat counter where you can order an absolutely phenomenal sandwiches. After pushing through the front door of Jimmy's Food Store you enter into a slightly cramped Italian grocery store that somehow still manages to have a cozy welcoming feel and also feels a little like you're in New York City. Head down one of the isles stocked with wine, fine olive oils, or fresh pasta straight from New York back to the meat/ sandwich counter. As you approach you'll notice people of all ages milling around waiting to collect their their sandwich when their name is called. The menu is posted up on the counter and signs for $2.00 canoli's, fresh pizza dough, sausage, and cheeses decorate the wall behind the counter.
There are 12 sandwiches on the menu... my personal favorite? The Italian Stallion.... ok ok we already know I love to eat... and this is a mammoth of a sandwich. Seven meats, two cheeses and a salad mix that contains lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, cherry peppers, romano cheese, and a olive oil it's more than you can handle in one bite. But after that first bite.....you'll be hooked and decide to become a life long patron of Jimmy's. While the Stallion is my standby favorite, I've also had their delicious meatball sandwich and the Italian Beef. Jimmy's meatballs... are homemade, amazing, tender and tasty. The DiCarlo's have been making and selling them for years. The beef, you ask? Tender and juicy.... you can't beat it, at least not that I've found. From what I can tell native New Yorkers, old school Italian imports, and Dallasites agree with me.
Once you hear your name called and grab your sandwich head down the last aisle grab a beverage and head up to the front to pay. If you have friends and time for a leisurely lunch grab a bottle of wine and let Jimmy's open it up for you and grab a table. You can get a small table right inside and peruse Italian cookbooks or at a little table outside on a sunny day. Unwrap your white butcher paper encased sandwich and dig in to the delightfulness that is Jimmy's. Even though Jimmy's Food Store is a little out of the way... it is completely worth the trip... and be prepared after one taste you'll be making multiple trips and bringing your family and friends. Don't forget it's a great place to find that elusive pasta you are looking for or get some fresh pizza dough for pizza night. Just in case here's the website for you http://www.jimmysfoodstore.com
This is the Italian Roast Beef on the left and the Meatball on the right... of course I made someone share with me! :) Buon mangiare! (Good eating!)